NHL
| Name | Regular season | Playoffs | Total | Avg PIMs | Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Ray Scapinello | 2,497 | 428 | 2,946 | — | Retired |
| Gérard Gauthier | 2,339 | 258 | 2,615 | — | Retired |
| Mark Pare | 2,167 | 30 | 2,223 | — | Retired |
| Randy Mitton |
| 165 |
| 2,274 |
| — |
| Retired |
| Brian Murphy | 2,069 | 304 | 2,455 | — | Retired |
| Swede Knox | 2,039 | 208 | 2,250 | — | Retired |
| Shane Heyer | 2,015 | 212 | 2,307 | — | Retired |
| Dan Schachte | 2,006 | 223 | 2,281 | — | Retired |
| Brad Lazarowich | 1,973 | 205 | 2,245 | — | Retired |
| Brad Kovachik | 1,970 | 195 | 2,269 | — | Active |
| Ron Finn | 1,960 | 288 | 2,260 | — | Retired |
| Kevin Collins | 1,956 | 304 | 2,288 | — | Retired |
| Leon Stickle | 1,948 | 219 | 2,176 | — | Retired |
| Kerry Fraser | 1,905 | 254 | 2,187 | — | Retired |
| Pierre Racicot | 1,878 | 249 | 2,220 | — | Retired |
| Don Koharski | 1,872 | 266 | 2,169 | — | Retired |
| Mike Cvik | 1,869 | 91 | 2,010 | — | Retired |
| Gordon Broseker | 1,863 | 219 | 2,096 | — | Retired |
| Scott Driscoll | 1,848 | 185 | 2,108 | — | Retired |
| Bill McCreary | 1,737 | 297 | 2,076 | — | Retired |
| Mark Wheler | 1,735 | 112 | 1,916 | — | Retired |
| Greg Devorski | 1,730 | 219 | 2,035 | — | Retired |
| Tim Nowak | 1,728 | 114 | 1,924 | — | Retired |
| Bob Hodges | 1,696 | 159 | 1,857 | — | Retired |
| Kelly Sutherland | 1,680 | 255 | 2,038 | — | Active |
