NHL
| Name | Regular season | Playoffs | Total | Avg PIMs | Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Steve Barton | 1,675 | 153 | 1,922 | — | Active |
| Wayne Bonney | 1,658 | 221 | 1,884 | — | Retired |
| David Brisebois | 1,635 | 98 | 1,847 | — | Active |
| Danny McCourt | 1,624 |
| 60 |
| 1,685 |
| — |
| Retired |
| Paul Devorski | 1,619 | 202 | 1,879 | — | Retired |
| Dan Marouelli | 1,619 | 190 | 1,845 | — | Retired |
| Jonny Murray | 1,615 | 203 | 1,921 | — | Active |
| Kevin Pollock | 1,609 | 218 | 1,913 | — | Retired |
| Eric Furlatt | 1,606 | 192 | 1,894 | — | Active |
| Ryan Bozak | 1,590 | 69 | 1,661 | — | Retired |
| Chris Rooney | 1,571 | 191 | 1,853 | — | Active |
| Chris Lee | 1,561 | 116 | 1,753 | — | Active |
| Jay Sharrers | 1,555 | 204 | 1,809 | — | Retired |
| Lonnie Cameron | 1,553 | 60 | 1,679 | — | Retired |
| Mark Shewchyk | 1,548 | 75 | 1,721 | — | Active |
| Dave Jackson | 1,546 | 83 | 1,690 | — | Retired |
| Dan O'Rourke | 1,544 | 210 | 1,852 | — | Active |
| Pierre Champoux | 1,518 | 28 | 1,582 | — | Retired |
| John D'Amico | 1,518 | 231 | 1,772 | — | Retired |
| Marc Joannette | 1,518 | 169 | 1,764 | — | Retired |
| Wes McCauley | 1,517 | 229 | 1,855 | — | Active |
| Dan O'Halloran | 1,513 | 212 | 1,796 | — | Retired |
| Tony Sericolo | 1,501 | 32 | 1,625 | — | Retired |
| Andy McElman | 1,500 | 2 | 1,549 | — | Retired |
| Derek Amell | 1,498 | 210 | 1,811 | — | Retired |
