NHL
| Name | Regular season | Playoffs | Total | Avg PIMs | Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Andy van Hellemond | 1,472 | 224 | 1,697 | — | Retired |
| Derek Nansen | 1,466 | 63 | 1,619 | — | Retired |
| Brad Meier | 1,460 | 93 | 1,634 | — | Retired |
| Michel Cormier |
| 1,455 |
| 96 |
| 1,647 |
| — |
| Active |
| Willard Norris | 1,455 | 73 | 1,529 | — | Retired |
| Pat Dapuzzo | 1,443 | 66 | 1,527 | — | Retired |
| Darren Gibbs | 1,429 | 16 | 1,516 | — | Retired |
| Terry Gregson | 1,428 | 158 | 1,592 | — | Retired |
| Jean Morin | 1,424 | 213 | 1,687 | — | Retired |
| Ryan Galloway | 1,408 | 23 | 1,511 | — | Retired |
| Brad Watson | 1,395 | 214 | 1,673 | — | Retired |
| Gord Dwyer | 1,383 | 134 | 1,618 | — | Active |
| Ron Asselstine | 1,364 | 87 | 1,454 | — | Retired |
| Tim Peel | 1,362 | 90 | 1,519 | — | Retired |
| Brian Mach | 1,347 | 2 | 1,426 | — | Retired |
| Ian Walsh | 1,322 | 30 | 1,431 | — | Retired |
| Rob Shick | 1,320 | 134 | 1,469 | — | Retired |
| Don Henderson | 1,293 | 10 | 1,359 | — | Retired |
| Steve Miller | 1,291 | 139 | 1,507 | — | Retired |
| Scott Cherrey | 1,275 | 181 | 1,566 | — | Active |
| Bob Myers | 1,274 | 122 | 1,397 | — | Retired |
| Don VanMassenhoven | 1,274 | 88 | 1,402 | — | Retired |
| Brian Pochmara | 1,270 | 64 | 1,423 | — | Active |
| Jim Christison | 1,251 | 45 | 1,297 | — | Retired |
| Steve Kozari | 1,239 | 146 | 1,468 | — | Retired |
