ECHL
| Name | Regular season | Playoffs | Total | Avg PIMs | Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Charlie O'Connor | 500 | 92 | 608 | 28.56 | Retired |
| Ray King | 497 | 57 | 558 | 36.13 | Active |
| Christopher Williams | 454 | 63 | 536 | 28.98 | Active |
| Mike Sheehan | 433 |
| 54 |
| 500 |
| 29.00 |
| Retired |
| Scott DeBaugh | 432 | 36 | 480 | 33.23 | Retired |
| Andrew Wilk | 410 | 68 | 489 | 31.47 | Retired |
| Patrick Richardson | 403 | 85 | 500 | 28.03 | Retired |
| Brady Fagan | 396 | 52 | 465 | 24.49 | Active |
| Mike Hamilton | 364 | 62 | 427 | 36.08 | Active |
| Logan Gruhl | 363 | 68 | 436 | 26.10 | Active |
| Nolan Bloyer | 354 | 47 | 413 | 24.16 | Active |
| Shaun Morgan | 350 | 81 | 440 | 27.65 | Retired |
| Quinn Schafer | 344 | 32 | 382 | 27.54 | Active |
| Steven Berry | 337 | 27 | 371 | 38.67 | Active |
| Alex Normandin | 330 | 74 | 416 | 27.69 | Retired |
| Tyler Puddifant | 327 | 44 | 382 | 30.98 | Active |
| Logan Bellgraph | 324 | 9 | 341 | 30.87 | Active |
| Rocco Stachowiak | 322 | 52 | 380 | 26.35 | Active |
| Tyler Hascall | 320 | 65 | 392 | 24.62 | Active |
| Davids Rozitis | 319 | 27 | 354 | 26.33 | Active |
| Steven Walsh | 318 | 41 | 368 | 31.96 | Retired |
| Shane Gustafson | 311 | 30 | 348 | 27.29 | Active |
| Bryan Gorcoff | 309 | 53 | 368 | 26.42 | Active |
| Sam Heidemann | 309 | 47 | 359 | 27.51 | Active |
| Zach Carson | 304 | 14 | 324 | 25.80 | Active |
