NHL
| Name | Regular season | Playoffs | Total | Avg PIMs | Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Trevor Hanson | 810 | 53 | 919 | — | Active |
| Thomas John Luxmore | 803 | 44 | 908 | — | Active |
| Ryan Gibbons | 790 | 92 | 941 | — | Active |
| Brandon Gawryletz | 759 |
| 22 |
| 844 |
| — |
| Active |
| Garrett Rank | 749 | 49 | 851 | — | Active |
| Devin Berg | 747 | 100 | 903 | — | Active |
| Kendrick Nicholson | 741 | 17 | 812 | — | Active |
| Jon McIsaac | 702 | 43 | 795 | — | Active |
| Tom Chmielewski | 700 | 3 | 760 | — | Active |
| Jake Brenk | 662 | 17 | 729 | — | Active |
| Andrew Smith | 632 | 46 | 727 | — | Active |
| Ryan Daisy | 625 | 58 | 735 | — | Active |
| Libor Suchanek | 606 | 32 | 696 | — | Active |
| Bevan Mills | 593 | 46 | 689 | — | Active |
| Travis Gawryletz | 584 | 17 | 650 | — | Active |
| Pierre Lambert | 582 | 16 | 642 | — | Active |
| James Tobias | 551 | 27 | 626 | — | Active |
| Chris Schlenker | 546 | 0 | 591 | — | Active |
| Peter MacDougall | 515 | 11 | 572 | — | Active |
| Tyson Baker | 509 | 9 | 561 | — | Active |
| Furman South | 486 | 7 | 537 | — | Active |
| Jesse Marquis | 477 | 30 | 546 | — | Active |
| Corey Syvret | 454 | 3 | 497 | — | Active |
| Kyle Flemington | 452 | 18 | 507 | — | Active |
| Julien Fournier | 452 | 12 | 500 | — | Active |
