AHL
| Name | Regular season | Playoffs | Total | Avg PIMs | Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Terry Koharski | 1,341 | 186 | 1,535 | 30.37 | Retired |
| Jamie Koharski | 815 | 49 | 865 | 36.92 | Retired |
| David Banfield | 752 | 70 | 823 | 36.93 | Retired |
| Tim Mayer |
| 31 |
| 764 |
| 32.74 |
| Retired |
| Chris Brown | 665 | 24 | 690 | 33.63 | Retired |
| Jud Ritter | 628 | 69 | 704 | 29.79 | Active |
| Chris Ciamaga | 613 | 60 | 674 | 39.47 | Active |
| Shaun Davis | 587 | 16 | 610 | 34.53 | Active |
| Brent Colby | 584 | 12 | 603 | 32.63 | Active |
| Carl Sasyn | 583 | 42 | 625 | 29.21 | Active |
| Fred Hudy | 563 | 8 | 571 | 30.39 | Active |
| Aaron Mills | 560 | 49 | 609 | 36.83 | Retired |
| Frank Murphy | 556 | 19 | 576 | 36.86 | Retired |
| Mark Lemelin | 551 | 78 | 630 | 34.74 | Retired |
| Jeff Smith | 517 | 16 | 533 | 28.52 | Retired |
| Ryan Hersey | 495 | 14 | 517 | 30.31 | Retired |
| Luke Galvin | 486 | 20 | 507 | 35.70 | Retired |
| Keith Kaval | 485 | 14 | 506 | 33.40 | Retired |
| Geno Binda | 469 | 46 | 522 | 28.33 | Retired |
| Jordan Deckard | 467 | 17 | 485 | 29.81 | Active |
| Dave Lewis | 442 | 37 | 486 | 29.37 | Active |
| Tommy George | 440 | 30 | 470 | 34.98 | Active |
| Jarrod Ragusin | 431 | 11 | 449 | 29.14 | Active |
| Jim Harper | 428 | 4 | 432 | 40.36 | Retired |
| Beau Halkidis | 427 | 84 | 511 | 25.33 | Active |
